home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- THE GREAT UFO DEBATE:
- INTRODUCTION
-
- In April of 1986, I attended the 10th Anniversary Convention and
- Banquet of the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims
- of the Paranormal (CSICOP). There I sat next to a charming gentleman
- named Lucien Kemble, who told me to my surprise that he was a Fran-
- ciscan monk. Fr. Kemble and I talked and dined together often at the
- convention, and we have maintained a correspondence ever since. His
- skeptical attitude towards the paranormal stems from his desire not
- to see the true works of God and Christ get lost in a flurry of meta-
- magical fluff and nonsense. As an accomplished amateur star-gazer, he
- views the beautifully integrated mechanics of the universe itself as
- the one true "paranormal" occurrence.
-
- In our correspondence, I raised with him my disagreement with
- CSICOP's attitude on UFOs. "SOMETHING is going on up there," I told
- him, "and Science is missing the boat." Rather than sneering at me
- condescendingly, as others have, he very politely and with genuine
- curiosity asked me my reasons for believing thus. It was then that
- the idea of a public electronic debate on the subject occurred to me.
-
- The fortieth anniversary of the traditional beginning of the UFO
- era presents an appropriate time frame for a reasoned, objective dis-
- cussion of the UFO issue, specifically, whether UFOs represent a gen-
- uine opportunity to add significantly to our knowledge of the uni-
- verse, or are simply a figment of the collective imagination. As Para-
- Net is philosophically neutral territory, a sort of electronic "Hyde
- Park" of the paranormal, what better venue for such a discussion to
- take place.
-
- Here, therefore, begins the second ParaNet Debate: UFOs, 1987 -
- After 40 Years, Have We Got ANYTHING? I will begin the debate with a
- brief article, which will be posted here and submitted to Fr. Kemble
- for his reply. Copies of the submissions will be sent to various
- others in the field, skeptics and believers alike, for their perusal
- and possible response. In addition, all ParaNet users are invited to
- participate. You can submit a response by typing it on an ASCII word
- processor and uploading it to Section 1 - Ufology, or if it is less
- than 2000 characters, simply post it to the message base. Non-users
- can simply send a typewritten submission of up to 3000 words to:
- ParaNet, PO Box 17675, Fountain Hills, AZ, 85268. (If you happen to
- have access to IBM-formatted disks, you can submit in that manner as
- well.) As ParaNet is an eleemosynary entity, we regret that we cannot
- compensate anyone for a submission; we ask that you do this in the
- interest of public education. However, all copyrights will be honored
- and posted as requested.
-
- The fruits of the debate will be stored in the ParaNet Library for
- reference by future generations of Truth-seekers.
-
- And now, let the debate begin!
-
- --Jim Speiser